The Best Cigar Ashtrays To Get In 2021 – Top Rated Models & Reviews!

Jeff Miller
Written by
Last update:

Just like a pipe, cigars and cigarillos are smoked. They’re one of the most popular forms of tobacco in the world.

While pipes can be enjoyed by anyone, cigars are often reserved for the most devoted of smokers. They are more expensive, take longer to enjoy, and, obviously, produce smoke. For that reason, there are a number of important considerations when picking the best cigar ashtray.

Below is a quick guide on how to choose the best cigar ashtray for your needs.

NameCategoryProduct
Limited Edition Large 8.75" Arturo Fuente Porcelain Cigar AshtrayBest OverallLimited Edition Large 8.75" Arturo Fuente Porcelain Cigar Ashtray
Prestige Import GroupBudget PickPrestige Import Group
The Big Easy Tobacco Accessories Square Grid Cigar AshtrayUpgrade PickThe Big Easy Tobacco Accessories Square Grid Cigar Ashtray

1. Limited Edition Large 8.75" Arturo Fuente Porcelain Cigar Ashtray

Our rating: 9 / 10

Limited Edition Large 8.75" Arturo Fuente Porcelain Cigar Ashtray

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Ashtray is made with highest quality porcelain and has a thickness of 2/3 inch
  • Available in multiple colors
  • Attractive antique style, which makes it ideal for a home decor
  • Custom made by the award-winning Fuente Cigars
  • Limited edition (only 2,000 made), so it is hard to find
  • Pretty sturdy, but watch out for the edges in case it’s dropped … they can break or chip off
  • Comes with free carrying case

Cons:

  • The downside is the risk of damage when shipped (almost a certainty)
  • Available only for special occasions

Besides being one of the best-looking ashtrays on the market, the Fuente cigar ashtray isn’t just durable but also is useful! This product is truly one-of-a-kind. It’s handmade by artisans in the Dominican Republic and is based on an antique design. It’s got a handmade, classic look that’s hard to find these days.

2. Prestige Import Group

Our rating: 9 / 10

Prestige Import Group

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • As it is designed for three cigars it can easily hold any cigar sizes
  • Perfect for the man cave, the patio, the bedroom, or anywhere
  • Does not trap odors
  • Made of real wood
  • Simple and stylish design
  • It is easy to clean and maintain
  • Easily portable
  • Heavy and durable
  • Affordable price

The Prestige Import Group 3 cigar ashtray, as the name implies, is an ashtray specifically designed to hold three cigars. While this might not seem much, it is actually the best in its class, and also very affordable. There are no other extra features on the top of it, except for the handles on the side.

It is made of real wood, making it durable and easy to maintain. It will not trap odors, so you can use it anywhere and will not get in the way. It is also easy to clean and maintain, easy to transport, is of a heavy and durable design, and is still affordable. It is also simple and stylish, perfect for the man cave, the patio, the bedroom, or anywhere.

3. The Big Easy Tobacco Accessories Square Grid Cigar Ashtray

Our rating: 9 / 10

The Big Easy Tobacco Accessories Square Grid Cigar Ashtray

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Sleek design
  • Has heavy bottom to avoid tipping
  • Sturdy and durable
  • Great quality for affordable price
  • Light weight, pretty portable

The plastic insert that comes with the ashtray is low quality. It’s better to buy glass inserts separately for better durability

This cigar ashtray is a hybrid of both stainless steel and plastic, which makes it pretty attractive while at the same time very lightweight. It is ideal for outdoor use while not being too susceptible to rust and corrosion. Since it has a high-quality bottom, you don’t have to worry about it tipping and spilling ashes all over your patio.

The ashtray is designed to look like a regular square ashtray. It comes with a built-in cigar rest that can hold up to three cigars at once. It also includes a removable plastic insert to capture ashes that are single cigar sized.

4. Quality Importers Ashtray 4 Cigar Crystal Ashtray

Our rating: 8 / 10

Quality Importers Ashtray 4 Cigar Crystal Ashtray

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Lots of capacity
  • It comes with a handle built in
  • Beautiful and decorative design
  • A good buy for the price
  • Sturdy, heavy, and high quality
  • The beads are shatterproof

Cons:

  • A little too small
  • Can be slippery if you have them full

8.5x4x2.8

5. Mantello Cigars Large Premium Black Ceramic Cigar Ashtray

Our rating: 7 / 10

Mantello Cigars Large Premium Black Ceramic Cigar Ashtray

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Measures 8.25" x 8.25" x 2.5"
  • Large enough to hold 20 cigars
  • Durable ceramic construction
  • Can be used indoors or out
  • Hardwood stand is included
  • Casters included
  • Works well as a center piece
  • Lid fits well
  • Hand wash only
  • Available in different colors

Cons:

  • Not suitable for smaller cigars
  • Lid can be challenging to remove

When it comes to outdoor living and personal enjoyment, owning a good cigar ash tray is a must have. No one wants to walk around holding a cigar when they are in the backyard, or when sitting by a pool. A large, or solid wood cigar ashtray is useless in these situations, as they will likely end up with the cigar falling out and ending up all over the place.

The Mantello Large Outdoor Ashtray solves this problem. It is large with a spacious area to set your cigar down without fear of it rolling off the edge. The outside lip of the ashtray has been carved on just the right angle, creating a groove to hold your cigar in its place. It comes with a hardwood stand, which is also perfect for outdoors.

Conclusion

The search for the best cigar ashtrays is not an easy one. There are thousands of choices out there, and they all look pretty much the same in the standard metal bowl type. It’s harder than you think to find the best cigar ashtrays, which is why we put this guide together.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
Limited Edition Large 8.75" Arturo Fuente Porcelain Cigar AshtrayBest OverallLimited Edition Large 8.75" Arturo Fuente Porcelain Cigar Ashtray
Prestige Import GroupBudget PickPrestige Import Group
The Big Easy Tobacco Accessories Square Grid Cigar AshtrayUpgrade PickThe Big Easy Tobacco Accessories Square Grid Cigar Ashtray